Skip to main content

BWCA land swap environmental review released

Aug 05, 2017 10:31AM, Published by Editor, Categories: Outdoors



This portage between Sawbill and Alton lake reaches to a plot of school trust land in the Boundary Waters. Derek Montgomery for MPR News file

By Dan Kraker, Minnesota Public Radio -Duluth - Aug 3, 2017

The Superior National Forest has released the draft of a proposal it hopes will settle a 40-year old controversy over about 50 square miles of state school trust land trapped inside the federally controlled Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. 

The state is required to manage that land to generate revenue for public schools; but the federal government is required to restrict development and manage the Boundary Waters as wilderness. 

The draft environmental impact statement released Thursday reflects a compromise reached five years ago by state and federal officials. But many environmental groups object, fearing it could pave the way for more mining and logging outside the wilderness. 

As proposed, the Forest Service would acquire about 31,000 acres of state school trust land within the Boundary Waters, in exchange for federal land of equal value outside the wilderness area, chosen from a pool of parcels of up to 39,000 acres. 

The Forest Service would then purchase the roughly 50,000 acres of school trust land remaining in the Boundary Waters from the state. 

"I think that this land exchange along with the hybrid option of purchase is really a win-win for everybody," said Superior National Forest Supervisor Connie Cummins. 

Forest officials back the plan because it allows the agency to consolidate ownership of lands within the Boundary Waters to protect the wilderness resource. 

Efforts to broker a compromise deal date back to 2010. Two years later, DFL Gov. Dayton signed legislation to expedite a land exchange and give the state authority to sell school trust lands within the BWCA. 

But the Superior National Forest still has not received funding to purchase the state parcels, despite applying every year since 2012, and some environmental groups have been wary of backing a partial exchange before money to purchase the remainder of the land is appropriated. 

Others want the federal government to purchase all the state school trust land within the Boundary Waters, and not exchange any federal parcels outside the wilderness in return. 

"This is simply a move to allow more intensive logging and to allow more mining outside of the Boundary Waters," said Elanne Palcich of Chisholm, Minn., with Save Our Sky Blue Waters. 

While the federal government would not give up mineral rights of any of the parcels it exchanges, transferring surface rights to the state would make it easier for possible copper-nickel mining projects to progress, Palcich argued. 

The public has about two months to comment on the draft review. The Forest Service has scheduled three open houses on the project, in Duluth, Mountain Iron and St. Paul, starting on Aug. 28.



  • Yoga at the Y

    08/21/2017
    06:15AM — 07:00AM

    The practice of breath control, meditation, and postures that increase strength, balance and flex...


  • The Johnson Heritage Post Art Gallery is currently accepting applications to exhibit for the 2018...


  • Youth Climbing Team

    08/21/2017
    09:00AM — 05:00PM

    Open to K-12 students interested in getting outside to adventure this summer. The team will explo...


  • Water Fitness at the Y

    08/21/2017
    09:00AM — 09:45AM

    This all-depths water workout will target health and fitness objectives by combining a variety of...


  • ForeverWell Cardio at the Y

    08/21/2017
    10:00AM — 10:45AM

    A safe and heart-healthy aerobics class to energize your lifestyle using low-impact movements tha...


  • Harbor House Grille - Open 11 to 8 Every Day

    08/21/2017
    11:00AM — 08:00PM

    Come join us at Harbor House Grille, featuring chef prepared, handcrafted food. Today's specials ...


  • Yoga at the Y

    08/21/2017
    12:00PM — 12:45PM

    The practice of breath control, meditation, and postures that increase strength, balance and flex...


  • Cardio/Strengh Class at the Y

    08/21/2017
    12:00PM — 12:45PM

    A strength training cardio class that targets the major muscle groups using various equipment and...


  • Lunch at the Senior Center

    08/21/2017
    12:00PM — 12:30PM

    Chicken Parmesan/Potato/Veggie/Dessert/Milk


  • Help us find our lost dog

    08/21/2017
    02:00PM

    Our 13 year old puggle got loose and wandered into the woods by Temperence River state park this ...


  • Pilates at the Y

    08/21/2017
    05:20PM — 06:05PM

    A blend of deep muscle toning, stretching, balancing and cardio intervals guaranteed to pump up y...


  • Co-Dependents Anonymous

    08/21/2017
    05:30PM

    Co-Dependents Anonymous is a Fellowship of men and women whose common purpose is to develop healt...


  • Join the Cook County Historical Society in celebrating a traditional favorite - Fishcakes! FRIDA...


  • Open Mic Every Monday at 6PM!

    08/21/2017
    06:00PM — 11:55PM

    Grand Marais Music Collaborative presents "Open Mic Night", every Monday at Grandma Ray's! The s...


  • The Johnson Heritage Post Art Gallery is currently accepting applications to exhibit for the 2018...


  • Qigong at the Y

    08/22/2017
    09:00AM — 09:45AM

    The practice of rhythmic breathing, posture and mental focus, using movement and sounds. Qigong t...


  • Boreal office closed Tuesday

    08/22/2017
    09:00AM — 04:00PM

    The Boreal office will be closed Tuesday. For urgent support dial 218-387-9471 ext 4.


  • Volunteer Opportunity: Catalog Mailing

    08/22/2017
    10:00AM — 12:00PM

    Help your local Folk School spread the word about our programming by helping us mail out catalogs...


  • Kids' Day

    08/22/2017
    11:00AM — 04:00PM

    During this time frame we have special activities for Kids’, every Tuesday from June 27 – August ...


  • Join us at Harbor House Grille, featuring Chef prepared handcrafted meals. Today's specials inclu...


  • Overeaters Anonymous

    08/22/2017
    11:00AM

    Overeaters Anonymous is a fellowship of individuals who, through shared experience, strength and...


  • Group Cycle at the Y*

    08/22/2017
    12:00PM — 12:45PM

    Multi-level workout with speed drills, hills and intervals. Cardio workout designed to get your h...


  • Lunch at the Senior Center

    08/22/2017
    12:00PM — 12:30PM

    Honey Glazed Meatballs/Potato/Cucumber Salad/Dessert/Milk


  • US Forest Service Special Presentation

    08/22/2017
    02:00PM — 03:00PM

    Each Tuesday, starting on June 20, U.S. Forest Service naturalists present on a different Northwo...


  • Help us find our lost dog

    08/22/2017
    02:00PM

    Our 13 year old puggle got loose and wandered into the woods by Temperence River state park this ...


  • Water Fitness at the Y

    08/22/2017
    05:20PM — 06:05PM

    This all-depths water workout will target health and fitness objectives by combining a variety of...


  • Yoga at the Y

    08/22/2017
    05:20PM — 06:05PM

    The practice of breath control, meditation, and postures that increase strength, balance and flex...


  • Yoga in Colvill

    08/22/2017
    05:30PM — 06:30PM

    All levels Yoga Class in Colvill at the Town Hall. No registration required. Mats available. J...


  • Join the Cook County Historical Society in celebrating a traditional favorite - Fishcakes! FRIDA...


  • Group Cycle at the Y*

    08/22/2017
    06:15PM — 07:00PM

    Multi-level workout with speed drills, hills and intervals. Cardio workout designed to get your h...


  • Trivia Night at Grandma Ray's

    08/22/2017
    07:00PM — 09:00PM

    Trivia Night from 7:00-9:00pm every Tuesday down at Grandma Ray's.


Minnesota Fire Danger
Boreal Ship Spotter - larger view here